Publication Ethics

Journal of Qur’an and Hadith

COPE Standards

English Edition

Ethical Commitment Statement

Journal of Qur'an and Hadith is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics and preventing all forms of publication malpractice. The journal follows internationally recognized ethical guidelines in scholarly publishing to ensure the integrity, credibility, and quality of academic publications.

All parties involved in the publication process—including authors, editors, reviewers, and publishers—are expected to uphold ethical principles and professional responsibility throughout the editorial and review process.

Responsibilities of Authors

Originality & Plagiarism Manuscripts must be entirely original. Proper citations are required. Plagiarism or self-plagiarism is strictly unacceptable. Similarity screening is mandatory.

Multiple Submission Simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to more than one journal or publisher constitutes unethical behavior and is prohibited.

Data Integrity & Authorship Fabrication or falsification is prohibited. Authorship is limited to those with significant academic contributions. All co-authors must approve the final version.

Conflict of Interest Authors must disclose any financial, institutional, or personal conflicts that may influence the research findings or interpretation.

Responsibilities of Editors

Evaluate manuscripts based purely on academic merit, originality, and scope relevance.
Maintain strict impartiality and freedom from discrimination (gender, race, religion, or nationality).
Preserve absolute confidentiality regarding submitted manuscripts prior to publication.
Recuse themselves from handling manuscripts with potential conflicts of interest.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Treat all received manuscripts as privileged and confidential documents.
Conduct reviews objectively, constructively, and professionally without personal bias.
Identify uncited relevant literature and alert editors to potential textual overlaps.
Decline review assignments whenever competitive or personal conflicts exist.

Ethical Oversight The journal reserves the right to reject manuscripts violating publication ethics, retract published articles when misconduct is identified, and take necessary actions to preserve academic integrity.

Publication Malpractice Sanctions Plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, citation manipulation, and undisclosed conflicts are strictly prohibited. Proven misconduct results in immediate rejection, article retraction, and formal notification to the author's home institution.

Edisi Indonesia

Pernyataan Komitmen Etika Publikasi

Journal of Qur'an and Hadith berkomitmen menjaga standar tertinggi etika publikasi dan mencegah segala bentuk malpraktik penerbitan ilmiah. Jurnal ini mengikuti pedoman etika publikasi akademik internasional guna memastikan integritas, kredibilitas, dan kualitas publikasi ilmiah.

Seluruh pihak yang terlibat dalam proses publikasi—termasuk penulis, editor, reviewer, dan penerbit—wajib menjunjung tinggi prinsip etika dan tanggung jawab profesional selama proses editorial dan penelaahan berlangsung.

Tanggung Jawab Penulis

Orisinalitas & Plagiarisme Naskah harus asli. Kutipan wajib dicantumkan secara tepat. Plagiarisme atau self-plagiarism tidak ditoleransi. Pemeriksaan penapisan Turnitin wajib dilakukan.

Pengiriman Ganda Penulis dilarang mengirimkan naskah yang sama secara bersamaan ke lebih dari satu jurnal atau penerbit lain.

Integritas Data & Kepengarangan Fabrikasi, falsifikasi, dan manipulasi data dilarang keras. Kepengarangan hanya untuk kontributor signifikan. Seluruh penulis wajib menyetujui versi akhir.

Konflik Kepentingan Penulis wajib mengungkapkan konflik kepentingan finansial, institusional, maupun pribadi yang dapat memengaruhi hasil atau penafsiran penelitian.

Tanggung Jawab Editor

Mengevaluasi naskah berdasarkan kualitas akademik, orisinalitas, fokus jurnal, dan metodologi.
Bebas dari diskriminasi ras, gender, agama, kewarganegaraan, maupun pandangan politik.
Wajib menjaga kerahasiaan naskah dan informasi editorial secara ketat sebelum terbit.
Tidak menangani naskah yang memiliki hubungan konflik kepentingan pribadi/lembaga.

Tanggung Jawab Reviewer

Memperlakukan naskah sebagai dokumen rahasia. Dilarang mendiskusikan tanpa izin editor.
Penilaian wajib objektif, konstruktif, dan profesional tanpa adanya kritik pribadi.
Melaporkan indikasi tumpang tindih teks atau dugaan plagiarisme kepada dewan editor.
Menolak tugas review jika terdapat konflik kepentingan dengan penulis atau institusi.

Pengawasan Etika (Ethical Oversight) Jurnal berhak menolak naskah yang melanggar etika publikasi, menarik artikel yang telah dipublikasikan apabila terbukti melakukan pelanggaran, dan mengambil tindakan editorial demi menjaga integritas akademik.

Sanksi Malpraktik Publikasi Plagiarisme, fabrikasi, falsifikasi data, publikasi ganda, manipulasi sitasi, dan konflik kepentingan tersembunyi dilarang keras. Pelanggaran berakibat pada penolakan naskah, penarikan artikel, hingga pelaporan resmi ke institusi asal penulis.